I would like to see the stats on that please. Thank you.
The reasoning I shared came from a meeting I sat thru at a National Fastpitch Coaches Association national convention where a Rules Committee discussed this and many other proposals for the sanctioning bodies. A representitive of the committee shared the information and members were ask to vote for or against making the recommendation. National ASA and USSSA reps were in the room. I was not allowed to vote because only committee members have a say but many questions were asked including why the change back. The vote was almost unanimous to support metal cleats to be reinstated.
I admit I was surprised at the support and if given a chance to vote, I'm not sure I would have raised my hand but the percentage numbers shared supported metal cleats. I can tell you the debate lasted a long time with many examples being shared by coaches from all facets of the game. That rules committee for NFCA seems to have a lot of influential power with sanctioning bodies but the NFHS still leads the way in setting the tone for school ball while ASA, USSSA, and the rest run their own shows. NFCA only makes recommendations.
It was after that meeting I was asked if I had any interest in being a part of the national board as a representitive for travel teams. I had been nominated for the Ethics Committee and lost the election on a ballot with about 12-15 names from across the country. Without knowing the outcome of the election, I turned down the chance as you can only serve on 1 committee at a time.