Who quits their team in the middle of a season!?

Heavy Hitter

Active Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2014
Messages
295
Reaction score
33
Points
28
Not knowing all the FACTS...I would say this is middle school or non varsity ball since they are struggling to get players.

Anyhow, the quotes from 1950/1960s while classic and good, do not mean much for most under 40 in todays sports environment. I have to shake my head when I see post like, "I would make them finish what they started" especially; when its someone elses kid...

I have no issues when one is critiquing their own kid but there is a lot of those that live in a glass house and throw a ton of stones... (My old quote that gets over used)

I know of ladies that had to leave a team at all levels for various reasons and guess what...They are doing ok without the doom and gloom or end of the world for player and team that posters like Heavy Hitter seems to forecast.

The bottom line is, this kid may not have the support needed coaching or parental, she may have actually NOT wanted to play but did because she was pressured by her friends, she may have been a solid player and hung her team out to dry just to do it..
This case just has too much information not known to form blanket statements ...
I do not see a person leaving a youth sports team causing them down the road to leave jobs, relationships, families etc ...

Wow.. do you just make crap up because I don't see were I said any doom or gloom I did state... Kids today do have "It is all about me attitude." Kids today have no problem quiting if the they don't get there way. If the idea of saying you made a commitment you should stand by it is from the 50/60 then we are in a world of crap.. Because it people like Cards that tells kids do what you want, who gives a crap about anyone else and if you don't get your way just quit.
 
Last edited:

CoachB25

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
121
Reaction score
2
Points
18
I apologize for reposting this as I have cut and pasted this from another site I belong to. My daughter was the "underclass volleyball player of they year" for her HS as a freshman. She could do most phases of the game well and really matched up well for our HS when playing a consistent state caliber team in various tournaments. She sat bench on varsity and never got into a game but we had a senior laden team so that was that. The next year, and after all of the summer training etc., she was doing really well. The week the games were to start, she was supposed to have worked her way into the varsity starting lineup per a conversation with the varsity coach. BB went to practice the following Monday (first game on Tuesday) but the trainer noticed she had a bad strawberry on her butt/hip and told her to get it wrapped. She did in athletic PE and so, never missed a minute of practice. The HC walked in, saw the gauze and wrap and asked her what she did. She told the truth and said she played in a softball exposure tournament and had to slide a lot. She also said she was fine and didn't need the gaze but the trainer told her to put it on. The HC went ballistic and told her that she was done with softball players. My daughter never got into one match at either the JV or Varsity level. She sat bench in every varsity game. She practiced with the varsity and never once missed a minute of practice. After a couple of weeks, when JV players started playing over her, it was apparent that she was never going to get into a game. I was furious and she wanted to quit. I told her no. She could learn a lot about not being the star of the team. The AD and everyone else went out of their way to avoid me. Me and my wife never missed a match and were there for her each time she cried after another disappointing game on the bench. We went to the banquet and made our daughter thank the coach for the opportunity to be on the team. The following fall, I gained my daughter as a member of the golf team and she did exceptional.

In no way could I list all of the positive things she learned but I know that she would come home proud of herself and how hard she worked regardless of what this coach thought. I know she gained a new understanding of dedication and work ethic. I know that she learned the differences in types of coaches and so knew the type of coach she would never be. I know she gained a new kind of respect from her peers who all knew what was going on. This coach had a terrible season and was fired the following year. You all raise your dd the way you want but beware of the "other lessons you are teaching."
 

Heavy Hitter

Active Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2014
Messages
295
Reaction score
33
Points
28
And when this is the coach as opposed to a player, do you still expect a kid to grin and bear it?

Been their with my DD so yes... you made a commitment follow it through. She doesn't have to play the following season but she will learn more on how to deal a bad situation/ crappy coach then just quiting.
 

AkronCarPro

Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2014
Messages
93
Reaction score
8
Points
8
Location
Akron, ohio
It's not hard to anonymously dog a kid in public but you're not walking in her shoes. If she's #10 on a team that only has 10 players then it sounds to me like it's been a pretty long year. It's easy for you to say she should sit there and smile, be a team player and cheer on your kid. If the roles were reversed, how would your kid feel. And be honest.

Like I said, two sides to every story. We don't know the dynamics between the kid and the coach, etc. It's easy to tell little Susie to suck it up when you don't know the whole story.
 

CARDS

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2014
Messages
1,311
Reaction score
349
Points
83
Location
COLERAIN
Website
www.wearecolerain.com
Given the "right circumstances" I would advise anyone to do what they feel is best for them or their family even if that meant leaving.
Most teams and coaches I know want players and parents that want to be there, are willing to work hard and are supportive of coaches and teammates.

While as a manager or coach I hated to lose anyone, however having been around I understand sometimes that is the best option.

As a coach I must have been blessed over the years to be part of a strong organization and teams where if a lady or family decided to leave (and we did have a couple over the years) their leaving did not affect the team or our plans for the team. (Just like most of the solid teams out there).

I agree, there are many life lessons that can be learned outside of the fundamentals of the sport itself as the ladies learn to compete, however at some point in ones journey they may need to weigh the pros and cons of continuing to be part of the team or organization etc..

My personal feeling is a person should never stay in a situation that is "not healthy" no matter if it is sport, job, relationship, religion etc. Staying in a bad situation can not only affect the player but it may have a negative effect on the whole team. Now the decision to leave should not be done without really stepping back and asking oneself is leaving the best or only option we have? In most cases parents and players stick it out, and I guess at the seasons end there is a feeling of accomplishment that they made the best out of the situation no matter what the cost ends up being finically or emotionally for them.
 
Last edited:

Run26

Active Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
468
Reaction score
168
Points
43
Allowing a child to quit on a commitment only sets them up for failure in the real world. I'm not saying one should stick around if the scenario is abusive or out of line but to allow them to quit because of playing time or other BS terms is hardly best practice. Teaching them to honor their commitment should in most cases improve communication skills and teach the player how to deal with a tough situation. Encourage the player to speak with the coach and find out exactly what the issue is. This not only opens up dialogue it also makes the coach aware that the player is interested in his/her opinion of their ability.
It can also allow the player to encourage the coach to communicate more regularly with regards to expectations versus a concentration on teaching/coaching mode. Most coaches have no clue on how to communicate with 12 - 18 year old girls and think they operate the same as a boy. Ding! wrong answer.
Bottom line, if you teach your kid that quitting is okay you set them up for a multitude of different majors, jobs and probably boyfriends. Working to improve a situation is hard but quitting is easy. Unfortunately, it's how a lot of America operates these days.
 

steeler

New Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2014
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
Points
1
If we can get these messages of not quitting sent to Sam Bradford(Eagles quarterback) for now, I'm sure that this will help him make his decision;)
 
Joined
Feb 11, 2016
Messages
43
Reaction score
0
Points
6
Who quits their team in the middle of a season!? Then player/parent doesn't even have the decency to tell the coach and is a no-show at the next game. Leaving the team with only 9 players for the game. Not a hypothetical. This really happened to our school ball team today.

Ruined my day too, i was suppose to umpire my first time in my town the home jv game thst had to be cancelled cause they had to send the girls over fornthe varsity game.
Hope they can get a few back from injury and jv can play again
 

Similar threads

Top