Older DD (17) has the Tanels w/pitchers toe. They are true to size. Going into her second season and they are in excellent condition. With other store-bought brands, she use to go through 2 pairs per season. One rubber cleat did break off (partially) on the Tanels from dragging on the pitching rubber (I think). Also, she has been good about not wearing them on concrete and I think that is helping.
Younger DD (14, catcher) just got Ringors & loves them. Ordered them wide and 1/2 size bigger.
Both girls wear them 5/6 days a week now that it's warm enough to be outside and they are holding-up well.