No feedback on All-Star, daughter has never used it. Is she just little or young also? If young, I would take a look at the Worth Liberty catchers gear, it's what my dd used when she was young and the reason I suggest it is the straps on the chest protector is velcro Makes it so easy for them to take it off and put it on in a hurry between innings. If older, I would suggest Diamond iX3, the chest protector has snaps, can't think of a good description, you would have to look at them but not the same old clips that are a pain to use. Secondly they come in several lengths and colors in the chest protector (2" increments)and leg guards (1" increments)that you buy separately which was great for my dd because she is petite but has long legs so if we bought them in a kit one of them would not have fit properly.