"Politics" is a part of everyday life!!!... Everything from who makes the "A" 8u rec team to who plays, to who makes and plays on a high school team and who gets a scholarship to play softball for another 4 years! I'm not sure the Girls All-Ohio Softball voting is an example of politics at it's most EXTREME, but no doubt I'm sure it's as much a part of the process as everything else in life is. Rotte, you have surely been blessed with your daughters' success! Congrats to you and to them!
To answer the OPs question, the following has to happen:
1. Your HS school coach MUST be an active member of OHSFSCA and attend (I believe) 3 meetings during the year (or something like that).
2. Your HS school coach (at the end of the HS season) must attend the District meeting if the above requirements were met. He/She then must submit your DD's name and stats, as well as make a brief case as to why she deserves to be "All-Ohio," at the the district meeting.
3. All of the competing coaches will then have your DD's info in front of them along with all of the other nominated players and will vote.
4. The results will be based on the number of votes received from ALL of the participating coaches.