Depends on how much you want to spend. You can get an easton or mizuno for under 100 bucks and they will do well for just school ball. If she planns on catching into the summer, you wil want to go with a better quality and have to spend a little more. My dd destroyed both of her easton mitts in a year to year and a half. She is now on two years with her nakona and it still feels new but we went with the buckaroo. It is the top end and has a bufalo palm and kangaroo back. We payed quite a bit for it but she catches for schoot team (hopefully, as a freshman) and all summer for travel. You can get entry level nakonas for 150 or so.