Each bat has it's own distinctive feel for the most part and each player will "take" to a particular bat. The two biggest factors in bat selection for your DD will be how it feels swinging and the confidence she has in it. That said, I wouldn't limit myself to the top 5.
Completely agree. My 13 yr old tried all the top brands. The Mizuno Power Carbon was her choice, which surprised me. She's almost a year in with it, and loves it.