DD is a pitcher in her Jr. year of college, and has two Nokona gloves. Going into her freshman year, she thought her first one was "worn out", and we got her another one in preparation for college. At the time, we didn't know of Bretman and his magic. Well, an assistant coach on her college team basically rebuilt her "old" glove, padding and all, and it was
better than new!
I believe the Buckaroo is the Kangaroo Back glove, which is what DD has. The Kangaroo hide makes the glove incredibly light. Her Nokonas felt soft and broken in from day one. She's terrible about glove conditioning
, although she is very good at keeping a ball in the glove's pocket in her bag. The team is buying them new gloves this year, so who knows what she'll wind up with.
A well made glove should last a lifetime if cared for properly. I agree with the advice about consulting Bretman. He has seen and worked on many, many gloves. If you want to know what the best made gloves are, ask the guy who's had them all torn apart and knows how they're built.