How did you decide if your player was good enough for travelling?

default

default

Member
We have started an organization 2yrs ago Just like Hilliarddad talked about.

Our 10u is made up of 8,9,and 10 yr olds. We are taking them to tournaments that they can compete in. and can win and also get beat. We are family oriented and have outstanding coaches and access to a college coach and two well known pitching and hitting coaches.
with the LunaChix your DD can start at 10u and finish at 18u. the watch her go off to college.

Start them easy and then turn up the heat slowly. 99% of them can take it, and learn and have fun
 
default

default

Member
I got lucky. My ex-wife took my dd at 10 to a tryout against my wishes. I didn't think she was ready. I was wrong, and she has benefited from the 2 extra yrs of travel. That's why I say throw her to the wolves. Take her to several tryouts. Watch the coaches. You can usually tell pretty quick who are teachers and who aren't. Sign up with a teacher of the game. She'll be fine and a year from now you'll be saying "Thank God I did!!"
 
default

default

Member
i coached a rec all star team and we went to 4 tournaments and won all 4 she played well so it seemed natural plus she had a great work ethic to improve with
 
default

default

Member
For me it was real easy.... The head of the rec program came up to me when she was 9 going on 10 and asked me to put her on a travel team because he was afraid she was going to hurt someone.;&
 
default

default

Member
I got lucky. My ex-wife took my dd at 10 to a tryout against my wishes. I didn't think she was ready. I was wrong, and she has benefited from the 2 extra yrs of travel. That's why I say throw her to the wolves. Take her to several tryouts. Watch the coaches. You can usually tell pretty quick who are teachers and who aren't. Sign up with a teacher of the game. She'll be fine and a year from now you'll be saying "Thank God I did!!"

I encourage people that have doublts to do just as wgman said, go and "scout" the coaches too. He's right, if you don't see the spark or interest that the coach has to teach at the younger ages, you should probably keep looking. Develop first, win second, and either way fun will fall in-line.
 
default

default

Member
There is some good answers here. With all the different levels of play, there is usually a travel team right for every girl who wishes to play at that level. A lot just depends on what the young lady wants to do. Is she ready to make the commitment to practicing almost daily to improve her game?
 
default

default

Member
My dd came up to me after a rec game and began to tell me how awesome she was! So I figured it was time to give her ego alittle reality check. Granted their rec team walked all over everyone. Now it's alittle different story. She does not come up and tell me about her awesomeness!!;) She does well in the travel world, but is not walking all over anyone!

Mike
 
default

default

Member
A different twist...

Let's say instead of starting hard core travel ball at 9 or 10, your DD just plays rec. ball, and has time to hang with her friends at the pool? Maybe the family has the time (and money) to take a REAL summer vacation? Your DD can "just be a kid" during her summer off from school. Let's say she's 13 or 14 before she jumps into REAL travel ball.

What do you think the consequences would be?
 
default

default

Member
Sammy what is a vacation? Went many years that softball was our vacation with my oldest.. With my youngest it was easy. At 4 she was ball girl. T ball at 5 to rec.. 8, she played on a young 10U team. She was hooked early and then she became a DD ( Dollar Drainer). I know I have more $$ in her softball bag then I paid for my first car.
Sammy the good news is many teams a first timer can play for now. Not so years ago.
This sport has grown, look at all the camps and clinics that were not around 10 years ago.
 
default

default

Member
When dd was little (1-4th grade), she would complain every summer when rec ball was over that she wanted to play more games. When she was 9, a local rec coach started a 10U local travel team and she played rec and local travel(games every weeknight). She still complained that it wasn't enough. We took her to a travel try-out and let coach decide if she was good enough. Now, when she has a weekend off in the summer, she seems lost!

On the other hand, our son loves little league baseball so when he was 10 we forced him to be on a travel baseball team-"Just try it-you'll love it". We knew it wasn't for him when he skipped around the field after the last weekend game singing a cute little song called "Yea! The season's over". He hated playing every weekend!

Trust me your kids will let you know if it's for them very quickly!
 
default

default

Member
A different twist...

Let's say instead of starting hard core travel ball at 9 or 10, your DD just plays rec. ball, and has time to hang with her friends at the pool? Maybe the family has the time (and money) to take a REAL summer vacation? Your DD can "just be a kid" during her summer off from school. Let's say she's 13 or 14 before she jumps into REAL travel ball.

What do you think the consequences would be?

Consequences... FREE TIME!!! It's all relative as to what the consequences could be. Could cost valuable experience and seasoning, could put them into a situation that she can't recover from, may not make a difference if she is an incredibly fast learner and a super athlete, may not allow her to get on an exposure team or super travel team due to experience, may not matter if she just wants to play on a somewhat competitive team. Again, it's all relative to wants, needs, and what she is willing to do or not do to get "there".
 
default

default

Member
Thanks to all those that replied. Travel ball is normal to my daughter because that is what her older brother played. He's now playing HS ball. I helped start and coach his team all the way through 8th grade. She also has played all-stars so going to tourneys is something she has experienced and she does enjoy hanging out with her friends and playing games.

I'm going to be watching her carefully this season. If she continues to enjoy it and is able to progress through the season as I expect I'll probably encourage her to tryout. And her "trying out" means that I'll be a coach on her team most likely. I won't head coach, as I want to be sure I'm there for my son's last two years of HS ball, but I'll be a dedicated position coach (hitting, catching) on the team.

The only reason I think that I'll be coaching is first, I'll always step forward and help when I can, and second, the local HS feeder team (10u) only had a few show up at tryouts last year so it is going to take someone to step up and get it going. I'll take the lead as long as a head coach is found.

This all assumes that I feel my daughter is minimally ready, which I think she is.
 
default

default

Member
A different twist...

Let's say instead of starting hard core travel ball at 9 or 10, your DD just plays rec. ball, and has time to hang with her friends at the pool? Maybe the family has the time (and money) to take a REAL summer vacation? Your DD can "just be a kid" during her summer off from school. Let's say she's 13 or 14 before she jumps into REAL travel ball.

What do you think the consequences would be?

The friends she hangs out with are the other girls who will be trying out for the teams as well. So her social circle is the girls on her basketball team (she plays travel basketball) and the ones she plays softball with/against in her league.

If you take two kids of equal natural ability the one who plays against a higher level of competition for a longer period of time (without burnout or injury) will have an edge over the player who did not. Waiting until the player is 13 or 14 may backfire because their Jr. High teams are tryout based. Also the players that have been playing more competitively will probably get the starting spots on the Jr. High team. Again that is for two players of equal natural ability and does not take into account if the player who waited has an awesome mom or dad that can help her, an instructor, etc.
 
default

default

Member
I'll give you an example of the difference between starting early and waiting until 13 or 14 to jump into travel. My dd is 14, and a freshman in high school. There are 3 travel ball girls on the JV. My dd and another girl are equals behind the plate. My dd is one of the slowest girls on the team, and she's the starting shortstop. Why, because outside of the other catcher, she is the best trained softball player. She's not more athletic than any of the kids on the team, she's just a better trained softball player. Oh yeah, and she's got a cannon attached to her right shoulder.
 
default

default

Member
We started out with the 2nd & 3rd DD'S moving on to travelball at 9 and 10 years of age. They tried out with a couple of established travel programs and made them both, but we decided to go with the team that was a little more local, who also offered them spots a couple of days later, and it was a very good choice for their first year in travelball. Both were considered All-stars in our local rec league and we wanted to challenge them (physically/mentally) by playing on a team full of All-Stars and competing against the best players at there age. The 10 year old adjusted better, as she was one of the tallest and more outgoing kids on the team. She batted higher up in the lineup and played a key defensive position. The 9 year old had to learn early on to work hard, and to accept batting 8th or 9th and playing RF/CF.

I remember the very first tournament up at Spano Dome and seeing the Pitts. Power & Indy Dreams pitchers pretty much dominate my little All-Stars and wondering what the heck did I get my DD's into...lol. Later in the year, we placed 2nd in a tourney and both girls are sitting in the back seat holding their tropheys. The 10 year old was all smiles, as she had played really well, but the 9 year old was crying. I ask her what was wrong and she said "Daddy, I didn't help my team at all...I didn't get 1 hit the whole tournament" in between sobs. My heart sank and I told her that she played great defense, even throwing a couple of girls out at 1st and 2nd from the outfield. And that we would work really hard on her hitting and everything would be alright. She ended up not starting very much the next couple of tournaments. But she hung in there and by the end of the year we won the NSA Eastern Wolrd Series in Chicago, and she had the 2nd or 3rd highest average on the team for the tournament, starting every game.

The funny thing is, they both experienced growing pains each and every year as we continued to challenge them. And although the slumps still come each and every year, they both now know how to battle through adversity much more quickly without Dad or Mom getting involved. The good thing is they both still have passion playing HS and Travelball, with the dream of someday playing in college.

I would say one of the keys is when they hit 7th or 8th grade, that you really listen to what they want and let them make some of the decisions on what extra-curricular activities they want to pursue. I know I had to bite my toungue and go through 2 years of middle school cheerleading with one of them. I did not like it at all, but I forced a smile and supported her 100% during her practice and events. In the long run it really did strengthen our relationship, as she really knew that her Dad was proud of her and would always have her back no matter what she pursued.
 
default

default

Member
We fostered our DD before adopting her a few years back, so our goal when she arrived at age 10, was to get her involved in SOMETHING...she started with rec ****** and softball (mainly cause she had a pretty good swing playing in the yard)...so she loves both, plays pretty much anywhere, but on her rec team she met 2 girls who were playing "travel"...DD thought they walked on water, wanted to pitch, everything...
when she turned 11, still the same goal, keeping her active (she was in band too at the time, chess and choir too)...but after rec ball season was over, she tried out for the all-star team and didnt make it..she was bummed out..but that friend she met the year before, and now the jv pitcher she plays with now, asked her to come to a tryout in the winter..she made the team, i found the OFC and its been travel ever since...
i dont regret not having her for 10's, btu i do wish she was living with us earlier...now i am saddened to think of her being a freshman and being gone is 4 years...
whatever u do, enjoy the time u have and know it's never too late
 
default

default

Member
DD first picked up a softball at 13, saying "dad, I want to tryout for softball." Three years later, she gets a couple of college letters a week. She works hard and has a lot of god given talent. I just think it depends on a lot of factors.
 
Top