8494 - I agree. Mix it up. Make it unique. Last year we attended an ASA qualifier in NY and the girls received a trophy that had a sponge type softball in it that spinned when your pushed it. The team received a plague with a built in clock. Very nice. We are 16s. The girls loved them. They also like getting t-shirts/hoodies, etc. So as much as adults will say trophies are dust collectors (true), the girls still like getting trophies and medals. It's also neat when you go to different tournies and get something different/unique.
I'm older now, but still have my trophies from when I played travel, so there is something to be said for that too, I think. JMHO.