Re: Also a (so called ) dropped 3rd strike questio
Runner from third scores, runner from second is out, batter returns to the plate with a 2-2 count, nobody on base and two outs.
The rules specifically state that this is not an infraction by the batter. Running for first on a mistaken uncaught third strike is not a violation of the rules.
The defense needs to be aware of the count and the situation. If the catcher makes a play on a batter who is not entitled to run, that is a bad move by the catcher. The ball remains live on this play and any runners are free to advance with liability of being put out.
As the umpire, there are a couple of game management techniques that can head-off these kind of plays.
The first is announcing the ball/strike count clearly and often. The count especially should be announced whenever there are either three balls or two strikes, as on those counts the next pitch is likely to have an impact on the playing action. This helps to get everybody on the same page and reduce confusion.
Secondly, if a batter tries to advance to first when she is not supposed to, the umpire should loudly make a call to stop her.
For example, on a (real) uncaught third strike with fewer than two outs and first base occupied. If the batter tries for first, within her first few steps I'm repeating, "Batter out, batter out!", accompanied by the standard overhead fist out signal.
On this play, as soon as the batter leaves the box I'm loudly calling, "That's only two strikes, batter. Get back in the box!".
Good game management by the umpire can lessen the possibility of these "keystone cops" kind of plays. But good coaching can help, too! The defense still has the responsibility to know the count and game situation and the good sense to not make unnecessary plays on batters who are not entitled to advance.
