NCAA Umpiring

default

default

Member
I've been watching the umpires in the Oklahoma game and in the Missouri game Friday night and they just keep blowing calls. It's almost like they should just figure out what they want to call on the bases and then go opposite. Just terrible. They're all in good position, too. They just keep missing the ones that are semi-close. It's really not that hard. The guys who make it to the super regionals should be a lot better than this.
 
default

default

Member
Of course, when an ump finally got one right -- the Tennessee first base coach and the play by play announcer both showed how ignorant they were of the rules. A batter hit a hard grounder to the right of the first base line. It traveled in foul territory by four or five inches all the way to the first baseman who was playing about five feet in front of the bag. The player, standing in fair territory, reached across the line and appeared to have touched the ball, which then continued in foul territory into right field. This, of course, is a foul ball all the way. As soon as the player touched the ball, it was foul and dead. The first base coach argued right away that it was fair. You could see me mouth bullsh==t at the umpire. The announcer, who has no clue ever, explained that it depended on whether the first baseman touched the ball and "it looks like she might have." The color commentator, who is supposed to be an expert, should have immediately corrected her and said, it doesn't matter where the player is. It only matters where the ball is. It's unfortunate.
 
default

default

Member
The commentators in that game, Pam Ward and Michele Smith, made a couple of other erroneous statements during the game.

- While runner was returning to 1B after over running it, they said the runner was in danger of being put out because she was returning in fair territory. The runner had not made any motion except to return to 1B.

- When A&M made the pitching change in the 6th, Ainsley (P) replaced Clopton (Flex/LF) and Lanphear (DP) played LF. They said Dumezich (starting P) was now the DP because she wasn't playing defense.
 

Similar threads

N
Replies
0
Views
33
NCAA.com > softball d1 articles and video
N
R
Replies
0
Views
62
Ryan Connors |NCAA.com
R
R
Replies
0
Views
69
Ryan Connors |NCAA.com
R
R
Replies
0
Views
53
Ryan Connors |NCAA.com
R
Top