I hate getting involved in all this and honestly all are entitled to their own opinion. Here is all I have to say about my first hand experience coaching one of the 10U teams that travels out of state and having a 10u daughter who plays. Just my opinions!!!
What matters as a FATHER:
-I spend time with my daughter (one on one) every day and sports has been only one part of that bond. We talk and share our days as we practice and I learn to read her expressions and emotions. Sometimes we work on pitching, hitting, fielding and other times we just hit a movie or go to the mall. We bond and continue to grow a close relationship which is very important to my wife and I. She fights to be the best at school, sports, and in everything she does and the close relationship with family, team, and friends help her to improve in all aspects of life each day. She wants to succeed for team, dad/mom, but mainly for herself! She is driven to play the best, and that is what helps her work harder every week. Many of these girls even at 10 would lose interest playing rec ball because they just naturally want the competition, so if the KID loves it then why should adults on the outside looking in judge them or their parents? So my daughter chooses to play on a team that has similar desires and that was her decision to make! That does not mean that girls who want to just play for fun should not get the same respect. Every kid is different.
Many of these girls arrive home from school and do a softball workout for an hr or more 3-4 times a week. I can only speak for my experience but even when I am tired and want the break she demands the practice. Then she hits the outside with the neighborhood kids and spends the rest of the evening in our garage playing games, on the trampoline, playing basketball in backyard, or playing in the woods at back of property. She is a kid! She spends no time on video games, watching TV for hours on end, or spending it staring at her phone. There is nothing wrong with electronics in moderation that but I am happy that she is focusing on activities more. Late at night she watches something with the entire family most evenings, and I just count my blessings that we have a bond that provided this connection were she wants to be around her parents and sister. No matter if it is a sport, school, music, or anything else this is a bond we all need with our kid. So I do believe that these parents who travel across the country for their kid are doing many positives for the kid. As long as the KID is wanting this experience and loves the sport!
This is a typical travel weekend for us and I am sure same for most:
We arrive at hotels in another state that becomes a romp house for our 10 young girls to play and bond in all weekend. They laugh, and play in the rooms and hallways and build memories that will last forever and go to dinner every night as a team. This all starts before they step on the field and battle it out. They play hard and work hard, and all that practice gets a chance to be put to the test. They love to see what all that hard work amounts to when they have the big hit, make the great play, or win the big game. It is not cheap to travel like this, but our kids get much more then just a game against top competition from it!
Team Schedule growth
I think no matter the level this is a positive way to approach it)
25% of games against a weaker team: (We work on secondary positions, areas of weakness in past tournaments, and how to win with dignity) YES!!! We focus on respect for teams we beat bad
50% against teams at your level: (We learn how to win the close games, how to be focused on every pitch and play, and how to fight to the last pitch)
25% against the better teams: (We have to learn to lose with dignity and use it to FUEL our desire to improve and grow) VERY IMPORTANT TO LEARN
**These are all qualities that will help these girls in school, work, sports, relationships and life. They need to experience the feeling of all.
We try to play a 25/50/25 schedule if possible. So if you have to travel to achieve this and parents are on board then go for it.
Now with all of this said there is still a simple truth!
My daughter is a pitcher, fielder, hitter, and well rounded player. She loves the sport, competition, her team, and all that it brings. Will that be the same in 6 years?
I have no clue!!!!! I will cherish every minute of it, support her, push her, and continue to build our bond stronger. So no matter what she does down the road she will have support and a good foundation to attack anything that comes her way. I truly believe that sports will always be a big part of her life, but she is not getting scouted at 10 and I want her to enjoy the sport. She just enjoys the sports greatly when competition is high! That is for some kids, and not for others. That is why there are lots of teams to pick from at 10U at all sorts of levels.
Best of luck to all the teams this summer and I look forward to meeting more of you at the parks. Just enjoy the time you have with your kids cause as I have experienced so closely lately with the tragic deaths of young kids in our local communities it can end way too fast. These kids are the best part of us!!!!!
God bless!