What would you do as a parent/player if.......

default

default

Member
Again..... not my daughter. I just heard of this situation and was kinda shocked. I have never heard of a coach telling a player that they were "not allowed" to use their bat. Especially BEFORE the season even started. From what I understand the coach hadn't even seen the player use the bat in a single game. Just wondering what everyone thought. Does not effect me or my daughter in any way.

Ok, no problem, but that would be my advice to the parents of that girl. The effect of the coach's decision on the girl will be determined by how her parents react. If they support the coach, the girl will go along with the decision and be fine. If the parents complain, the girl will llikely complain. If the player changes to a quality composite bat that isn't way too big or small for her, she will still be able to hit just fine if she's a good hitter.
 
default

default

Member
A coach has to have the ability to help a player perform and if that means not letting her use a certain bat then that is the decision. It would be nice if the topic was open for discussion but in the end talking to the coach about it is all you can do at this time.

Without watching the player swing it is unknown if the bat has been too heavy for her all this time or what is going on. It could be that the coach is seeing a flaw in her swing and is commonly attributed to a bat being too heavy. Or maybe he is wrong.
 
default

default

Member
I'm simply guessing but if the coach knows what they are doing and they have come to a breaking point of frustration over this, I'd say it's obvious that coach and staff are totally convinced the girl is incapable of hitting pitchers at this level because she's late with her swing due to the bat being too heavy. I'd advise the coach to talk with the parents, and then have a conference with the family to convince this kid to try something different. I know there are a few coaches that can simply be on an ego trip but this sounds more like a coach at the end of their string.

If all this is a ****ing match to get her way, the kid will soon find herself on the bench or worse----looking for another team. Good points JoeA.

It's upsetting to coaches, particularly male coaches, when the girls have a sentimental attachment to a piece of equipment that no longer is functional or practical. Just a quick anecdote; my daughter was a sophomore in high school when I noticed during a spring scrimmage she was running like she had hurt herself. After the scrimmage, I asked her what was wrong. She finally fessed up her cleats were too small and were hurting her feet. Of course like a good parent I had my moment of glory to jump on my soapbox and declare this wasn't my fault because I asked before the season if she needed anything and she told me "no." "Then why didn't we get you new cleats?" Her answer was that these were her favorite because she remembered how much trouble I went thru to find and buy them for her the year before and they were good luck to her. She didn't want me to worry and go thru all that trouble again---just 1 year later. All this went down just weeks after my Dad passed away and the 2 of them were very close.

I hate it when I help her make me look like an a**.

Maybe this kid has an attachment to her bat we aren’t aware of but that still doesn’t mean it’s right for her now. Life goes on and there may be more to the story.
 
default

default

Member
What I think (opinion): Have never (me) seen your DD bat (don't even know her). But maybe the coach see's something. If it were me I would have the player try another bat, but not threaten. He is only asking to try another bat; is he "tweaking" her swing?? hopefully not, especially if she is seeing a batting instructor. He is the coach and you are on the team because you wanted to be on the team; Parents and Players need to trust the coaches (respect) the decisions they make or ask of you. Hopefully the coach is coaching the team and not his DD and then the team. I am on both sides of the fence; i coach a summer team and my DD plays for High-school which I have nothing to do with.

Not sure how I want to explain myself; But as a parent (again) we need to trust the coaches and hopefully he has knowledge of the game and he must see something you don't. As a parent (watching my DD play High-school) I totally left her alone and let her experience it for herself; and that was great. I was not the parent to say to my DD "don't listen to him he doesn't know what he is doing" (example bat). As coaches we can tell what parent is doing that by the way the player reacts to us (coaches). It's not the end of the world...let him have her try another bat; if it works...great! If not, well you gave it a shot. The only way the bat works is if it hits the ball coming across the plate anyway.

A couple years back when I helped on a "daddy Ball" (and Mommy) travel team. I had asked a player to try another bat just one time (12u) at bat. Her mom (one of coaches wife) came in the dugout and said loudly...you are not using another bat, blah blah blah!!! needless to say that was my last year there...Thank God. But our Manager was great!! (seriously was..just wanted to put that out there)
 
default

default

Member
I can only echo every one else, sometimes coaches see and know things we don't. Would STRONGLY suggest this other girl ask coach to tell her the truth about why she can't use bat; if he doesn't, then have mom and dad go, and if that doens't work, go to org. director. Had a 9 yo girl show up this year for Rec ball with her dad's old 34" 38 oz. bat;&...
 
default

default

Member
I am amazed that an '05 Rocketech has any pop left in it. Is there a rule around how "recent" the certification stickers has to be on bats?
 
default

default

Member
This happened to my son a few years ago. The "coach" told him his bat was too heavy although, he was getting all kinds of hits and tried to not let him use his own bat. My husband, who played baseball until a few years ago and knows what he's doing and bought him the bat, told the coach don't try to change his bat again. My son went out with his own bat and hit a shot down 3rd base. "Coach" never said anything again.
 

Similar threads

Top