Why Youth Sports Team-Hopping is a Bad Idea

WWolff

"Suck A Little Less Today"
Joined
Feb 11, 2000
Messages
858
Reaction score
29
Points
28
Website
www.D1fastpitch.com
Why Youth Sports Team-Hopping is a Bad Idea

When things get uncomfortable on a youth sports team, many parents and athletes resort to team-hopping.

Let me explain first what team-hopping is not.

* It is not when your child finishes a season and moves on to the next level of competition.
  • It is not when your child changes club teams because he or she is ready for a new challenge.
  • It is not when your child loves a certain coach and leaves a team to go play for him.
Team-hopping is not just the act of changing teams.


Team-hopping is more of an attitude that manifest itself in a variety of ways:

  • When your child doesn't get the playing time he wants and so he jumps from team to team until he finds a coach who will give him what he wants.
  • When your child wants to play a certain position and so he switches schools or keeps looking for a team until he finds one that allows him to play his spot.
  • When your child jumps from school to school or from club team to club team because he can't get along with the coach or team?a very telling pattern.

In Tim Tebow's biography, Through My Eyes, A Quarterback's Journey, Tim talk about how his dad insisted he play quarterback and moved him to a school that would let him play it. I can't help but wonder if Tim would still be playing professional football if his dad hadn't done that? Even though he was a rockstar in college and even had a few bright spots in the PROs, could it be that the high school coaches were on to something when they concluded that maybe, just maybe he was better suited to another position on the field? Something to think about.

Change is good, Change is okay, but Youth Sports Team-Hopping is More about Avoidance Than Change

When you let your kids set a pattern of coach/team-hopping, what are you saying to them?
You are telling them it's okay to jump ship every time something gets hard. You are telling them that it's okay to run away when things don't go the way they like.
Don't hear what I'm not saying. I'm not saying you should never change teams or schools. I'm saying that when you let your child make team or coach-hopping a habit that continues throughout his youth sports career, you are encouraging a habit that can follow your child through the rest of his life.

I knew a young athlete who changed schools several times throughout middle school and high school, always looking for a better athletic situation. He did not move to a new neighborhood or town; he did not need to change schools. He changed because he was looking for something easier.

Today he's a young adult who's probably had half a dozen jobs in the past four years. The habit of jumping around began in middle school and continued to adulthood. He's constantly looking for something better, something easier, and when he doesn't find it, he figures it?s time to move on.

Call it a restless spirit, call it freedom, call it anything you want. But the truth of the matter is that the habit of running from uncomfortable situations also results in the deprivation of growth through challenges.

The decision to change teams or schools? for the sake of sports?should not be made lightly, and it should not be made habitually. Be finicky about your choice to change; counting the cost will most likely help you make wiser choices and keep you from jumping ship at every storm.


Call it a restless spirit, call it freedom, call it anything you want. But the truth of the matter is that the habit of running from uncomfortable situations also results in the deprivation of growth through challenges.

The decision to change teams or schools?for the sake of sports?should not be made lightly, and it should not be made habitually. Be finicky about your choice to change; counting the cost will most likely help you make wiser choices and keep you from jumping ship at every storm.

 
Last edited:

kjn40

New Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2014
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Points
0
On the reverse side of things.....organizations who refuse to honor requests to keep the majority of a team together due to their never-ending pursuit of a "perfect team". Therefore, team hopping is necessary. Unfortunately great team dynamics are sometimes sacrificed for stud players.
 

okiedad1961

Active Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2014
Messages
682
Reaction score
48
Points
28
Location
Green Oh
Especially when tryouts are over and you thought you had all your pieces for a team.
 

cincystorm

New Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2015
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
Points
0
It's a function of being your daughters BIGGEST fan that at one time or another we wanted and/or believed our daughter was better than she was, for the most realistic of us it probably only existed inside our heads and we were tough and pushed our daughters to match the player that we had in our heads. Where this becomes particularly dangerous and harmful to the game is when you have a parent that doesn't really know what a good/great player genuinely is, this I believe is where most of the people described above as team hoppers, this can be a novice in the game or as I have seen and experienced over the years a parent that has been around our game and should know better. Those are the ones that do the most damage. From experience their daughter talented as she is never reaches her potential, and many times is simply playing for the parent, for this player softball means, not developing lasting friendships, or becoming a part of the TEAM, it has always been about where he/she wanted her to play and at the position he/she wanted her to play. Let's face it unless the other parent puts a stop to it, what 10/12/14 year old girl is going to stand up to a parent. WWolf thanks for throwing it out there, I know many experienced coaches that see this situation coming their way and despite the young ladies talent will take a pass on her, I have always tried to honor the saying "Don't visit the sins of the parent upon the child", but Team Chemistry is so important and despite my experience that in many cases the young lady is a delight to coach and is well liked by her teammates, you could be asking for trouble. Now I know nobody on this site is one of these "team hoppers" but just for fun take a hard look at yourself and your daughters teams, if by the age of 18 she has played for 5 or more teams it might be time to examine your motives for switching teams! Just for fun! Like in all things the number could be 5 or 6 or 4, not carving it in stone, just saying.
 
Last edited:

mike_dyer

Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2014
Messages
822
Reaction score
16
Points
18
I love these types of threads.

I remember once upon a time someone posted a similar article about girls throwing temper tantrums, having bad attitudes, etc. The article, like this one, was full of doom and gloom. Any kid who ever did such things was never make it at the next level and was destined to die homeless in the streets, etc, etc, etc.

A short time later someone commented that one of the little darlings of Ohio fastpitch had a habbit of showing her ### when things didn't go her way. The same people who loved the article were out in full force defend the kid. She had it rough growing up, you see, so screaming cuss words, kicking equipment, and launching her bat when things didn't go her way were quite the things for a high school kid to be doing.

You can all post what you'd like, but I'd lay a dollar down that any coach posting otherwise would take the biggest problem child out there if her family came knocking. They would do it today and probably even wave her fees. They may even pay her dad to fly her around the country. I've seen it happen, I know I'm not the only one.

Oh, by the way, a major premise that the article was based on was shot down weeks before it was ever posted here.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/12723790/tim-tebow-philadelphia-eagles-reach-contract-agreement

Anyone else think it may have happened because his dad sent him to another high school?

But hey, enough of that. Don't mind me, fellas, you guys keep on truckin. Don't ever let facts taint the fairy tales you're living in.
 

wow

Active Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2014
Messages
837
Reaction score
56
Points
28
Location
Right over here!
The OP article sounded more about HS then travel softball. Team hopping has a negative connotation. Kinda like job hopping. Early in our adult lives how many of us have worked in the same jobs since we were 14 or 15? if you have great. But my guess is we all have moved around for a multitude of reasons. Those reasons were about the right fit, and professional growth, and earnings potential. Although kids don't play for money, fit and future potential are huge is deciding where a kid should play. The point is everyone has reasons for leaving/staying and trying to pigeon hole that choice into a three or four reason list seems acute. Team selection is about the right fit for your situation. If its not right, its not right.

I am not advocating leaving every year for the next best thing or shopping around for your DD so she can play SS for 1b. Rather trying to isolate the reasons why people leave into a laundry list is rather shallow.

I believe the premise of the OP was to work through adversity and challenges, not to run away from them and try to give examples of when a kid should work to get better, listen to a coach because another position is better suited, or understand their playing time is not what is most important to the team. Its sometimes about what is best for the team and understanding when that time is.
 

DynastyFastpitch

Active Member
Joined
May 20, 2015
Messages
139
Reaction score
40
Points
28
Location
Springfield
What makes me chuckle is when multiple organizations "claim" the same player if that girl makes it to the college level. That girl might have only played one year for a team at 12U, then moved on but her name is on the college signing list for that organizations website as well as the others.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

Top