MN only used 1 of their 3 berths to 14UA last year and none the year before and only 2 of 3 the year before that. But this year 12 of the best teams are battling it out for the 3 spots to Moline this weekend at ASA State and I would guess all berths will be used and reasonably earned.
I think the system could be better, to crown a true National champ it should be IMO finish high at State to qualify for regionals, finish high at regionals to qualify for Nationals. Take teams from each regional in proportion with participation and play a National tournament. That way if you have states with minimal participation and weak best teams they would get weeded out at regionals and you could have a reasonable number of teams at Nationals (220+ is a little ridiculous).
No thanks, the current system works better than what you propose.
When was there ever 220+ teams? The largest field I'm aware of was 164 last year for 16U. 164 teams seems excessive, but the right number will still be quite large in order to have a good national representation and include all the top teams. I don't think it is worth imposing an additional cost on all the teams of regional playoffs to pare it down some.
Let's look at our regions.
Northern Region: Minnesota gets 3 berths (but oftentimes doesn't use all of them) and South Dakota gets 1. It doesn't make sense to have a regional playoff between 2-4 teams from 2 associations.
Pacific Coast Region - SoCal (13), NorCal (4 state + 3 metros), Central Cal (4), Hawaii (1) and Nevada (1):
- Hawaii shouldn't have to make an extra trip to the mainland to keep their berth.
- We need our Regional to continue being a second chance for strong teams that didn't get a berth at their association championship. 21 good teams will be battling it out this weekend for 2 berths. Some of the teams are strong enough to finish top 20 at Nats and not all of them will get a berth.
The easier and better fix is to establish the number of berths for association and regional championships based on the number of teams competing. If they can't get the minimum number of teams for a berth at least 30 days in advance, they can open it up to outside teams to get the minimum.