Interesting article

default

default

Member
From a NJ newspaper...

NJ Softball: Play the part, look the part
By Sean Reilly
April 11, 2010, 12:08PM

After two decades of covering softball, you realize certain things will never change whether you like it or not. Parents yelling batting tips to their daughters and annoying chants that come from the dugout are two things that come to mind.

But if I were a member of the NJSIAA softball committee, there is one thing that I'd work hard to legislate. Is it too hard to ask that all members of a team wear the same uniform?

I'm not talking about the the occasional instance when a JV player might be called up to the varsity and have to wear a jersey that looks slightly different.

What really seems inexcusable to me are the many teams --- and there are loads of them -- that allow girls to wear their own personal batting helmets that aren't adorned with their school colors, but rather the colors of team they play for during the summer and fall.

Aside from the idea that it presents an unprofessional look to see a team whose colors may be blue or red have a batting order that has girls stepping to the plate in helmets that might be yellow or green, it needlessly sends other bad messages, like ones related to the importance of high school vs. club teams, or the thought that individual needs may be more important than those of a team, when the idea of high school athletics is to teach the opposite.

I watched a game recently where one team had every player wearing the exact same uniform -- including the same undershirt, jersey vest and batting helmet --- and the opponent had its nine starters dressed in seven different ways. Two infielders wore different colored visors -- (one's wasn't even a team color). One infielder wore sweat pants over her shorts, others wore pants inside of their shorts (and not all were the same color). A couple players wore white shirts under their jerseys; others wore blue. As for the batting helmets, as you'd might expect, there were a wide variety of colors and styles in use, very few in school colors.

When a team takes the field that way, it not only puts forth an unprofessional look for its players, program and school, the appearance could also reflect poorly on its inner-workings and how it functions on a daily basis.

Oh, and one other thing...surprise, surprise, the team that looked the part also won the game I just described above. Paying attention to a ``little'' thing like making sure its players looked the right way might not have won the game, but it's probably one of many small details that could have made the difference.



What does your school allow? Ours stated Nothing can be worn from your summer teams. I like it. Play for the team you are playing for in the season you are. Could you imagine a B-Ball team wearing their AAU stuff??
 
default

default

Member
I always had my high school team in the same helmet, but my travel team in whatever helmet they wanted. We could have forced them on the travel team to have the same helmet, but it seemed like an unnessary expense since they already had a perfectly good helmet.
 
default

default

Member
Unless the rule book they're using in New Jersey says differently, most require uniforms to be matching. Batting helmets generally fall under the guidelines of "protective equipment", not "uniforms", so there can be some variation there. But everything else- jersies, pants, shorts, sliders, socks hats of visors- is, by-the-book, supposed to match.

The instructions I've been given for regular season high school play in Ohio is to make some allowances for small differences in uniforms (that guideline might be enforced differently depending on just what part of the state you're playing in and who exactly is directing for your umpires). The goal of high school sports is participation and we don't want to deny a kid that opportunity because her socks don't match or her school system is too financially strapped to buy new, matching gear.

Minor uniform differences might be ignored. Gross differences, like different colors of uniforms, might get a kid held out of a game. These should, at least, be brought to the coach's attention so they can be informed of the proper rule. It can even be followed up with the league office or school's athletic directors. But, for regular season games, the uniform requirements may not be strictly and rigidly enforced. It's really at the discretion of the individual umpires and the end goal is to let the kids play the game, not to be the fashion police.

Playoffs are a different story. Here, the uniform requirements will be enforced exactly as outlined in the rule book.
 
default

default

Member
While I agree that it would be nice to have all the girls dressed exactly alike, simple economics sometimes prevent that from happening.

Our high school is "Pay to Play". Naturally, the girls all have their own gloves and bats. We also buy our own socks, spikes, sliding shorts, mouthpieces, etc... We can't justify spending even more money on a helmet for travel + a helmet for school. And many schools in our area field a team without "team" helmets.
 
default

default

Member
Our school couldn't afford to buy 26 helments, might buy 4 and share. Plus we play in Ohio and the weather can cause a lot of different uniform look.
 
default

default

Member
They offered ours a chance to buy the helmets this year, I think Schuttes, with faceguard, for $25.00 in the school color.
 
default

default

Member
All and all, the idea is great but economically it doesn't make sense and from a safety/health perspective I don't want my kid wearing a HS Helmet that's been worn by hundreds of other kids and stuffed in moldy locker rooms in off season.

I can't help but feel this author is a parent of a Non-Travel ball HS Player. I don't know a travel player that wears their Travel Helmet at HS softball for the purpose of advertising their "travel" status.

Good idea, wrong motive, never fly universally.
 
default

default

Member
Yeah, I don't have a problem with them wearing their own helmets, especially vs. sharing the limited number of team helmets with each other. If the school doesn't have the budget to buy them all their own helmets, and I bet many do not, then I just think we need to be realistic here.
 
default

default

Member
I do not consider the batting helmet part of the uniform either. We are a pay to play school also. With that and Tournament ball expenses. I really don't feel like coughing up another 35 - 50 $ for a hemlet just so it matches the HS team.
We paid are fee for HS ball to the school ....
we paid additional money for pants ( the girls wanted them) I agree its cold in early march and April in NE ohio
practice shirt(s)
Spirit wear
New spikes this year
New Catchers gear ( she out grew her old set)
I am just happy that she can use her Tournament helmet .........
;&
 
default

default

Member
Our dd has two batting helmets, one in her school color, and one from last year's travel team which is black, which, thankfully, matches her new travel team colors this year. Plus black goes with everything. I believe every fastpitch girl needs a black batting helmet -- sort of like having that black skirt that goes everywhere.
 
default

default

Member
Ok other side of the coin now.... What do the boys do? Do they wear all different ones at the same said schools everyone has typed about? Do they wear different colored sweatshirts when it's cold out?

Not sure just asking here myself. I can say the two schools we've been with, the boys are all in sync in what they wear.
 
default

default

Member
My son plays high school and travel ball. On both teams the helmests match, BUT, the boys all share 4-5 helmets. Each team member does not have his own helmet. Funny----boys have less of a problem with that stuff.
 
default

default

Member
It's not a fair comparison.

In my school district, boys' sports get the best uniforms, the best equipment, the best fields, etc...
 
default

default

Member
Minor uniform differences might be ignored. Gross differences, like different colors of uniforms, might get a kid held out of a game. These should, at least, be brought to the coach's attention so they can be informed of the proper rule. It can even be followed up with the league office or school's athletic directors. But, for regular season games, the uniform requirements may not be strictly and rigidly enforced. It's really at the discretion of the individual umpires and the end goal is to let the kids play the game, not to be the fashion police.

Playoffs are a different story. Here, the uniform requirements will be enforced exactly as outlined in the rule book.

Stupid Rule!! My Varsity and JV uniforms are two different colors, and last year during the state tournament I was informed one of the JV girls I brought up could not play because she was wearing a different color uniform!! That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. Umpires/OHSAA are now the fashion police!!! I understand the logic of the rule, but there has to be some common sense when enforcing it. Wake Up America!!!
 
default

default

Member
Our school is not pay to play, but the girls buy their own uniforms. The coach said too many uniforms were not getting returned by seniors and girls who wanted them for senior pictures so now they own them. If someone needs assistance, it is available. They can buy the matching helmets, but that is optional. As far as sliders, I just bought my dd bright pink ones with padding so I hope they don't show...
 
default

default

Member
Stupid Rule!!

It might be. But it is a rule right there in the rule book that all coaches have access to before the season even starts. It's also in the pre-season guides that the OHSAA publishes. The uniform requirements are also published on the OHSAA web site.

I mean, it's not exactly like they slip this one in under the radar where nobody would know about it. :rolleyes:
 
Top