I think you've hit the nail on the head, a lot of Ohio teams have a mix of girls with different talent levels and differing views of what they want out of the travel experience. Thats why it is so important when picking a team that the goals of all the girls are the same. If your dd wants to go to a bcs or top 25 program, then she has to play with girls that have the same aspirations.
If you pick a team where your dd will be the stud of the team and she plays with other girls that do not have the desire, or skill set, to compete at the bcs or d1 level, the team will not be able to draw the coaches to see the one stud on the team. At that point you have to chose to either move on to a like minded team or resign yourself to take the looks from coaches that you can scrape up.
As for how many d1 schools are giving Ohio girls a serious look, the depends on the team. I guarantee the Ohio girls on the Bandits teams, had a group of big time schools watching just base on his rep. And none of the girls on his team expect any less than getting a BCS or D1 offer because they want to compete with the best of the best at all times.
Just check out the scholarships and the schools on the Bandits home page. nuff said
The Beverly Bandits - Illinois' Premier Girls Fastpitch Softball Organization